Women Whistleblowers in Corrupt Institutions: Risks and Strategies for Resilience

Abstract

This article explores women whistleblowers' challenges in communitarian corruption states, mainly focusing on a case study involving fraud in faculty recruitment at a homoeopathic medical college. It examines the symbiotic relationship between communitarian and kleptocratic economies and the organised corruption that permeates various levels of institutional hierarchy. The article discusses the systematic tactics used to silence such women, highlights historical and contemporary trends in India, and offers psychological strategies to navigate the dangers associated with whistleblowing. The intersectionality of caste, gender, and lack of political support is central to understanding the vulnerabilities of these women.

1. Case Study: Exposing Fraud in Faculty Recruitment at a Homoeopathic Medical College

1.1. The Symbiotic Relationship Between Communitarian and Kleptocratic Economies

In a communitarian corruption state, the recruitment processes within educational institutions often reflect the deep entanglement of communitarian and kleptocratic economies. In the case of a Government homoeopathic medical college, faculty recruitment was manipulated to serve the interests of both communitarian networks and kleptocratic elites. Communitarian networks, rooted in caste and religious affiliations, prioritise the appointment of individuals from specific social groups to maintain dominance and control within the institution. Simultaneously, kleptocratic elites exploit these recruitment processes for financial gain, demanding bribes from candidates to secure positions.

The symbiotic relationship between these two corrupt systems ensures mutual reinforcement: communitarian networks receive financial and political support from kleptocratic elites, while the elites benefit from the social control exercised by these networks. This relationship not only undermines meritocracy but also perpetuates inequality and erodes the integrity of the educational system (Hellsten & Larbi, 2006).

1.2. Systematic Bribery and Redistribution of Corrupt Gains

The fraudulent recruitment process at the homoeopathic medical college involved systematic bribery, with money flowing from the candidates up through the institution's hierarchy. The principal, in collusion with medical council members, orchestrated a scheme where faculty positions were sold to the highest bidder. This money was then redistributed, with a portion going to administrative staff, operational staff, and even support staff who played a role in maintaining the corrupt system. This organised corruption created a network of complicity, where each level of the institution was invested in preserving the status quo (Acemoglu et al., 2003).

1.3. Planning and Retaliation Against the Whistleblower

When a woman assistant professor at the college, who lacked political support, attempted to expose this fraud, she faced organised retaliation. With the support of administrative and operational staff, the principal initiated a systematic campaign to discredit and silence her. This included extending her practical hours without justification and isolating her from her colleagues. The coordinated nature of this retaliation reflects the deeply embedded corruption and the lengths to which those in power will go to protect their interests (Serban, 2018).

2. Tactics Used by Authorities to Silence Whistleblowers

In this case, the textbook tactics employed by authorities involved systematic planning to undermine the whistleblower's credibility and professional standing while raising concerns about her safety. The whistleblower, an assistant professor, found that as long as students were present in the classroom near her staff room, she felt safe. However, during lab hours when students were absent, the support staff and attendants deliberately disappeared from the department, leaving her alone on the floor. On one occasion, she noticed two outside construction workers were brought onto the floor above her office, and simultaneously, a colleague involved in the corruption intentionally extended the practical session, forcing her to stay one hour past the usual working hours. This unusual situation raised serious doubts about potential hidden intentions against her safety.

Previously, when undergraduate students went on a two-day tour, she felt insecure due to the isolation and sought refuge in the postgraduate room of another department, where she shared her concerns about systemic corruption with the postgraduate trainees (PGTs). However, the following day, she received a phone call from higher authorities, who reprimanded her and forced her to return to her department. These patterns of systemic censorship, control, and attempts to isolate her raised significant concerns about organised retaliation against her efforts to expose corruption. Such tactics are common in environments with deeply entrenched corruption, where the institution seeks to maintain an appearance of legitimacy while systematically targeting dissenters (McDonald et al., 2016).

2.2. Using Intuition and Strategic Presence

Despite the hostile environment, the woman used her intuition to navigate the situation carefully. Recognising the danger of isolation, she ensured she was always around students or in public spaces, reducing the risk of direct retaliation. This strategy protected her and helped her gather evidence of the corruption. The next day, she resigned from her position and decided to blow the whistle through a blog article, exposing the corruption in the safety of her home (Gleason, 2017).

3. Historical and Contemporary Trends in India

3.1. Challenges Faced by Non-Partisan Women Whistleblowers

Women who refuse to align with party politics or engage in corruption face significant challenges in India. Historical and contemporary trends show that such women often experience delays in receiving their salaries, pension paperwork, and promotions. They are also frequently isolated within their workplaces, excluded from important decisions, and subjected to character assassination. These tactics demoralise and marginalise women, discouraging them from speaking out against corruption (Bjørkelo et al., 2015).

3.2. Systemic Violence and Retaliation Against Women in Corrupt Institutions

The tragic incident at RG Kar Medical College, where a postgraduate trainee doctor was raped and murdered while on duty, followed by violent protests, underscores the severe risks that women in the medical and educational fields face, particularly in environments characterised by entrenched corruption. The subsequent mob attack on the college reflects the kind of systemic retaliation that whistleblowers may encounter in communitarian corruption states. This incident exposes the broader systemic suppression by authorities and political entities, where violence and intimidation are used to silence dissent and maintain control. The chaos and lack of adequate response during the protest highlight the deep-rooted corruption prioritising the protection of institutional power over individual safety. In the context of this article, the RG Kar Medical College case exemplifies the acute vulnerability of women in corrupt environments, reinforcing the urgent need for systemic change to ensure their safety and the integrity of whistleblowing efforts in sectors like healthcare and education. (The Hindu Business Line, 2024)

This tragic incident at RG Kar Medical College, where a postgraduate trainee doctor was raped and murdered while on duty, has taken a new turn, with the CBI uncovering a massive bribery and illegal medicine racket linked to the case. The investigation revealed that the victim had protested against these malpractices, which involved the diversion of state-purchased medicines to private stores and a corrupt transfer posting system for doctors. The CBI suspects that her protests may have made her a target, leading to her brutal murder. This incident underscores the severe risks that women in medical and educational fields face, particularly in environments plagued by entrenched corruption and retaliation against those who dare to expose it (The New Indian Express, August 20, 2024). This incident exposes the severe risks and tragic fate that women whistleblowers face in corrupt Indian institutions.

3.3. Case Studies of Retaliation

Several case studies from India illustrate the risks faced by women whistleblowers. For instance, in a notable case from Maharashtra, a female government employee who exposed corruption in a public works department was systematically harassed, leading to delays in her promotions and pension processing. Another case from Tamil Nadu involved a teacher who exposed exam malpractice; she was transferred to a remote location and isolated from her peers. These examples underscore the systemic nature of retaliation against women who challenge corruption (Cortina & Magley, 2003).

4. Psychological Strategies for Navigating Corruption Safely

4.1. Building Resilience Through Self-Awareness and Support Networks

To navigate the dangers of whistleblowing, women need to build psychological resilience. This begins with self-awareness—understanding their emotions and responses to stress can help them remain calm and focused. Developing a support network, even if informal, is crucial. This network can include trusted colleagues, family members, or external allies who can offer advice, emotional support, and, if necessary, assistance in emergencies (Charap & Harm, 1999).

4.2. Strategic Planning and Exit Strategies

Women should also engage in strategic planning, including preparing for potential retaliation. This might involve documenting all incidents of corruption and harassment, securing personal documents, and planning an exit strategy (Johansson & Carey, 2019). In the case study discussed, the woman’s decision to resign and expose the corruption from a safe location was a strategic move that minimised her risk while maximising the impact of her whistleblowing.

4.3. Leveraging Anonymous Channels and Public Exposure

Where possible, whistleblowers should consider using anonymous channels to report corruption. This reduces the risk of direct retaliation while bringing attention to the issue. If anonymity is not feasible, crafting a well-thought-out public relations strategy can help control the narrative and garner public support, making it harder for corrupt officials to dismiss the claims (Lewis et al., 2014).

5. Policy Recommendations

To effectively protect women whistleblowers in corrupt institutions, there is an urgent need for comprehensive and robust whistleblower protection systems. Drawing from the findings of Baljija and Min (2023), it is evident that legislation alone is insufficient; a multifaceted approach that includes both legal protections and practical support mechanisms is necessary. Policies should ensure that whistleblowers are protected not only during the investigation of their claims but also afterward, shielding them from retaliation such as professional isolation, delayed salaries, and career stagnation. Additionally, implementing a standardized index to evaluate the effectiveness of whistleblower protections across different institutions could provide a valuable tool for monitoring and improving these systems, ensuring that they are both effective and adaptable to various cultural and organizational contexts (Baljija & Min, 2023).

6. Future Research Directions

Future research should delve deeper into the intersection of gender and power dynamics in whistleblowing, as highlighted by Kenny and Fanchini (2023). Understanding the gendered reprisals that women face, particularly in male-dominated sectors, could offer insights into how to better support and protect female whistleblowers. Additionally, as Supendi et al. (2023) suggest, exploring less commonly studied variables in whistleblowing, such as the role of organizational culture or the impact of social networks, could provide new perspectives on the factors that influence whistleblowing behavior. Furthermore, studies like those of Menhard and Safrizal (2023) and Wahyudi and Tantia (2023) indicate the importance of examining the psychological and cultural barriers to whistleblowing. Future research should focus on how these barriers can be overcome, especially in collective societies where corruption is normalized, and whistleblowing is stigmatized.

Conclusion

Women whistleblowers in corrupt institutions face significant challenges, particularly when exposing deeply entrenched systems of corruption. The Government Homoeopathic Medical College case study illustrates how organized corruption operates at multiple levels and how those in power use systematic tactics to silence dissent. Historical and contemporary trends in India show that women who stand against corruption often face retaliation in the form of delayed salaries, stalled promotions, and professional isolation. However, by building psychological resilience, strategically planning their actions, and leveraging support networks, women can navigate these dangers and bring about meaningful change. Policy recommendations emphasize the need for comprehensive whistleblower protection systems, and future research should explore the nuanced gender dynamics and cultural barriers that impact whistleblowing, ultimately contributing to more effective strategies for protecting those who speak out against corruption.

References

1. Acemoglu, D., Robinson, J. A., & Verdier, T. (2003). Kleptocracy and Divide-and-Rule: A Model of Personal Rule. MIT Economics Department Working Paper Series.

2. Baljija, S. K., & Min, K. (2023). Evaluating the Effectiveness of Whistleblower Protection: A New Index. Data & Policy, 5.

3. Bjørkelo, B., Einarsen, S., & Matthiesen, S. B. (2015). Predicting proactive behaviour at work: Exploring the role of personality as an antecedent of whistleblowing behaviour. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 88(4), 635-656.

4. Charap, J., & Harm, C. (1999). Institutionalised Corruption and the Kleptocratic State. New Institutional Economics.

5. Cortina, L. M., & Magley, V. J. (2003). Raising voice, risking retaliation: Events following interpersonal mistreatment in the workplace. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 8(4), 247-265.

6. Gleason, K. (2017). Gaslighting as an Abuse Tactic: A Historical and Cultural Perspective. Journal of Family Violence, 32(4), 435-444.

7. Hellsten, S., & Larbi, G. (2006). Public Good or Private Good? The Paradox of Public and Private Ethics in the Context of Developing Countries. Public Administration and Development, 26, 135-145.

8. Johansson, J., & Carey, M. (2019). Silencing and obstructing whistleblowers: Exploring the tactics of workplace mobbing. Work & Stress, 33(2), 187-204.

9. Kenny, K., & Fanchini, M. (2023). Women Whistleblowers: Examining Parrhesia, Power, and Gender with Sophocles’ Antigone. Organization Studies.

10. Lewis, D., Brown, A. J., & Moberly, R. (2014). Whistleblowing, its importance, and the state of the law. The International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 37(1), 71-77.

11. McDonald, P., Charlesworth, S., & Graham, T. (2016). Developing a framework of effective workplace sexual harassment complaints procedures. Gender, Work & Organization, 23(4), 422-434.

12. Menhard, M., & Safrizal, S. (2023). The Factors in Intention to Do Whistleblowing. Pattimura Proceeding: Conference of Science and Technology.

13. Serban, A. (2018). Corruption as an Organizational Disease. In Research Handbook on Organizational Ethics (pp. 235-252). Edward Elgar Publishing.

14. Supendi, S., Hasanudin, A. I., & Yazid, H. (2023). Exploring Whistleblowing Trends Through Bibliometric Analysis: A Global Perspective. Indian Journal of Corporate Governance, 16, 240-271.

15. The Hindu Business Line. Horror in hospital. [Internet]. 2024 Aug 19 [cited 2024 Aug 19]. Available from: https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/editorial/horror-in-hospital/article68539311.ece

16. The New Indian Express. (2024, August 20). CBI links bribery, illegal medicine racket to junior doctor's murder at RG Kar Medical College. The New Indian Express.

17. Wahyudi, I., & Tantia, E. P. (2023). Whistleblowing Practice in a Collective and Corrupt Society – A Case Study. Journal of Economics, Finance and Management Studies.

My post content